I’m not what one would call an emotional guy, so it would be highly unusual for something I came across in a magazine or newspaper to cause me to shed a tear. However, when I read last week about someone whose comic book collection sold for $3.5 million, I cried like a baby. Why, you ask, would some other person’s good fortune elicit such a response in me? Good question.
It dates back to my childhood in the 1950s. Each week, my parents gave me a dollar allowance, which was a small fortune for a pre-teen back in the day. I would hop on my bike, ride to the local newsstand, and spend much of my dollar buying the latest edition of ten cent comic books. Whatever was left over was spent on packages of baseball cards. Each package included a flat, square piece of bubble gum and seven baseball cards with the players’ photos on the front and vital statistics on the back.
This weekly ritual continued from the mid-Fifties through the early Sixties, during which time I amassed a collection of thousands of baseball cards and hundreds of comic books. Most of the comic books were superhero comics from DC Comics and Marvel. Yes, I admit that I would occasionally buy an Archie comic book and, in my younger days, I would sometimes pick up a Mickey Mouse or Donald Duck comic book.
By the time I got to high school, my collection of comic books and baseball cards, which I kept neatly organized in our finished basement, was unrivaled in my neighborhood. But when my mother opened up a knitting store just a few doors down from the very newsstand where I acquired my vast collections, she asked me to move my comics and baseball cards from the basement so she could store all of her extra yarns and knitting supplies down there.
Our house was a three bedroom split-level, but because we needed four bedrooms, my parents re-purposed what was originally intended to be a lower-level recreation room, which is what “family rooms” were called back then, into a fourth bedroom. My bedroom. When the closet for the recreation-room-turned-bedroom was constructed, a wide and deep storage shelf was built into the back. It was the perfect place for my collections and I carefully moved all of my cherished comics and beloved baseball cards from the basement to that shelf in the back of my closet.
Kid stuff
Then, when I went off to college, the unthinkable happened. I came home during one of my sophomore year breaks and went to hang up the clothes I brought with me. When I opened my closet door, I couldn’t believe what my eyes were seeing...or more precisely, not seeing. The huge shelf in the back of the closet was filled with skeins of yarn. I ran upstairs to the living room where my father was sitting in his easy chair reading the newspaper.
“Where are my comic books and baseball cards?” I screamed. My father calmly explained that he needed space in the basement for his tools, so he moved my mother’s yarns and knitting supplies to the back of my closet. “Okay,” I said, fearing the worst, “but where did you move my comic books and baseball cards?” I could sense from the expression on his face that what I was about to hear would, indeed, be the worst.
“That’s kid stuff,” he dismissively replied. “You’re in college now. You’re too old to be playing with comic books and baseball cards.” And then he dropped the bomb. “So I threw them all away in order to make room for your mother’s yarns.”
I’m not suggesting that my 50s-60s comic book and baseball card collections would have fetched $3.5 million, as did the 30s-40s collection of the guy in the article. But I had some classic baseball cards, including rookie cards of Mickey Mantle, Roger Maris, and Harmon Killebrew, along with a whole host of cards, all in pristine condition, of mid-century baseball legends. And my comic book collection was vast and most were in great shape, having been read only once or twice.
So let’s put it this way, I’m reasonably sure that my two collections, had they not been unceremoniously tossed out by my father, would have permitted me to have retired by now and to feel financially secure for the remainder of my life.
As I learned during my Werner Erhard est training in the early Seventies, what is, is, and, after all these years, I have forgiven my father, who, in his defense, was clueless as to the true worth of what he had so casually discarded.
Still, reading about the 3.5 million dollar take on fewer comic books than I owned, not even including my immense collection of baseball cards, did bring about a strong, visceral reaction as I pondered not what is, but what could have been.

Recent Comments